Two stars, two standout styles. On October 26, 2015, Sienna Miller and Supergirl actress Melissa Benoist both stepped out in striking all-black ensembles for their appearances on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. Naturally, we have to ask — who wore it better?
Melissa Benoist’s Glamorous Strapless Look
Melissa Benoist curls her hair for an interview on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert at the Ed Sullivan Theatre in New York on October 26, 2015 (Credit: Patricia Schlein / C.Smith / WENN)
Melissa, the lead actress in the latest superhero TV series “Supergirl,” talked with Stephen about her character serving as a feminist role model.
Melissa Benoist stuns in a strapless lace-accented black dress with a thigh-high slit paired effortlessly with classic black pointed-toe pumps
For her interview, she wore a strapless black cocktail dress with a slit paired with Brian Atwood “Patty” d’Orsay pumps.
Melissa Benoist shows off her sleek style in glossy black Brian Atwood d’Orsay pumps with pointed toes and stiletto heels
Brian Atwood Patty Patent Pumps
Sienna Miller’s Boho-Chic Vibe
Sienna, on the other hand, went a little more boho-chic for her interview.
Sienna Miller wears her blonde hair in a messy bun for an appearance on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert on October 26, 2015, in New York (Credit: Nikki Nelson / WENN / FayesVision / Nicky Nelson)
The actress paired a black Roland Mouret dress with block-heeled sandals to promote her upcoming movie “Burnt.”
Sienna Miller layers a classic camel coat over a sheer black Roland Mouret dress, finishing the look with bold snakeskin-textured block-heeled sandals in New York City
She tossed a three-button camel coat over her ensemble.
Sienna Miller shows off her feet in sleek black snakeskin block-heeled sandals with a peep toe and ankle strap
Who Wore It Better: Melissa or Sienna?
We think Melissa won this round. What about you? Steal Supergirl’s style with a pair of half d’Orsay pumps.
Jessica Simpson Claudette Pump, $42.95 – $84.99
Or go for 90s boho-chic with block heel sandals like Sienna.
Marni Black Jewel Block Heel, $955
While Melissa nailed her all-black interview look, it’s far from the only time she’s impressed with her style. Let’s take a peek at some of her other standout fashion moments.
Melissa Benoist’s Other Red Carpet and TV Looks
Also known for her portrayal of the titular character in the CBS/CW DC Comics-based superhero drama series Supergirl, Melissa has an estimated net worth of $4 million. She married American actor Chris Wood in early September 2019 at a private estate in Ojai, California.
Melissa Benoist dazzles in a metallic pink tiered dress with strappy silver heels, posing alongside her husband Chris Wood in a crisp white blazer at the 45th Annual Saturn Awards
In September 2012, after being cast as one of the newest members of Glee, Melissa Benoist attended the FOX Fall Eco-Casino Party at The Bookbindery in Culver City, California.
Melissa Benoist shows off her white teeth in a blush-colored dress
Melissa’s Blush Mini from Elizabeth and James
Melissa was a blushing babe in this similarly blush-colored dress. Though fitted and a mini, the dress retains a delicate and romantic vibe because of its ruching, blouson style, and prim 3/4-length sleeves:
Melissa Benoist flaunts her sexy legs at the FOX Fall Eco-Casino Party at The Bookbindery in Culver City, California, on September 10, 2012 (Credit: Nikki Nelson / WENN / FayesVision / Nicky Nelson)
The dress also has this cute knot detail at the left chest, creating a draped look on the bodice that matches the ruching on the skirt:
Melissa Benoist shows off her sparkling blue eyes and elegant updo hairstyle, perfectly complementing her soft makeup and blush-toned dress
Melissa Benoist matched her blush dress with nude peep-toe pumps. This is appropriate, but this dress would look even better if accessorized with princess-worthy purple sandals or those gorgeous Sergio Rossi crystal satin ‘Song’ sandals!
Melissa Benoist is wearing this ‘Larissa’ knot detail dress from the Elizabeth and James Fall 2012 collection:
Elizabeth and James ‘Larissa’ Knot Detail Dress in Blush, $385.00
Before we wrap things up, let’s take a quick look at some of the most stylish shoe moments from Melissa Benoist and Sienna Miller.
Melissa Benoist and Sienna Miller: Iconic Shoe Moments
Both Melissa Benoist and Sienna Miller have made remarkable fashion statements with their choice of footwear. Let’s delve into some of their most memorable shoe moments.
Melissa Benoist’s Bold Red Pumps at PaleyFest
- Event: PaleyFest
- Outfit: Melissa turned heads in a structured silk ensemble that resembled chic pajamas.
- Footwear: She elevated her look with striking red suede Mansur Gavriel ballerina pumps, adding a pop of color to her outfit.
- More Details: Melissa Benoist’s PaleyFest ensemble featuring bold red pumps
Melissa Benoist’s Chic Appearance in One-Sleeve Satin Dress
- Event: ‘Waco’ World Premiere
- Outfit: Melissa graced the red carpet in a pink Solace London one-sleeved midi dress.
- Footwear: She complemented her dress with blush velvet sandals, showcasing her elegant style.
- More Details: Melissa Benoist’s chic look at ‘Waco’ premiere
Sienna Miller’s Glamorous Look in Lanvin and Jimmy Choo
- Event: ‘Live By Night’ European Premiere
- Outfit: Sienna captivated on the red carpet in a silky, two-tone Lanvin gown with a thigh-high slit.
- Footwear: She accessorized with Jimmy Choo ‘Pearl’ platform heels, adding sophistication to her ensemble.
- More Details: Sienna Miller’s striking red carpet look with Jimmy Choo heels
Sienna Miller’s Chic Appearance in Chloé Mini Dress
- Event: ‘The Lost City of Z’ Premiere
- Outfit: Sienna dazzled in a tiered plissé silk-organza mini dress from Chloé’s Spring 2017 collection.
- Footwear: She paired the feminine number with ankle-strap sandals from Gianvito Rossi.
- More Details: Sienna Miller’s feminine Hollywood look with Chloé and Cartier
Sienna Miller’s Bold Statement in Dior Gown and Marigold Heels
- Event: ‘The Lost City of Z’ Premiere at Berlin International Film Festival
- Outfit: Sienna stunned in a sheer floral-embroidered Christian Dior gown.
- Footwear: Her marigold-yellow heels made a bold statement, adding a pop of color to her ensemble.
- More Details: Sienna Miller’s sheer Dior gown and marigold heels at Berlin Film Festival
These moments highlight Melissa Benoist’s and Sienna Miller’s distinctive shoe choices, which reflect their individual styles and fashion sensibilities.