Nowadays, winners of talent-based reality shows like American Idol and The Voice are a dime a dozen, with few seeing any actual success after their wins.
However, this wasn’t always the case. American Idol was a groundbreaking primetime television show that first premiered in 2002. The winners and runner-ups from the first few seasons have achieved bona fide fame.
Carrie Underwood, flaunting her sparkling halter crystal-embellished gown and signature green eyes, is the richest American Idol winner of all time (Credit: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock)
The most successful American Idol alum, by far, is none other than country queen Carrie Underwood. Underwood’s fame has soared so far that many people forget that she got her start on reality TV.
Carrie Underwood dazzles in a black fringe mini dress and sparkling platform ankle boots while performing at the iHeartRadio Music Festival on September 23, 2011, in Las Vegas (Credit: Brian Friedman / Shutterstock)
Follow along as we take a trip down memory lane, revisiting the milestones that aided Carrie Underwood’s rise to fame.
Carrie Underwood’s Humble Roots in Oklahoma: Life Before American Idol
Like the legendary Merle Haggard song, Carrie Underwood is a tried and true Okie from Muskogee — or, at least, an Okie from the Muskogee metro area.
The singer was born and raised in Oklahoma, growing up on her parents’ farm in the nearby town of Checotah. She speaks fondly of her time there, noting multiple times that she had a special love for the animals on the farm.
Carrie Underwood sparkles in a champagne-toned beaded cocktail dress and jeweled ankle-strap heels at the 2005 Billboard Music Awards on December 6, 2005, at the MGM Grand Garden Arena in Las Vegas, Nevada (Credit: Featureflash Photo Agency / Shutterstock)
Underwood developed an interest in singing at a very young age, taking every opportunity to perform at her church, talent shows, and other local events.
It was evident that Underwood was highly talented, even as a child, earning her an audition with Capitol Records at the age of 14. Though the deal ultimately fell through, this wasn’t the end for Underwood’s career — thankfully!
2004: Carrie Underwood’s American Idol Audition That Started It All
Although the country music singer herself has said that she never initially thought she would pursue a career in singing (having earned a degree in communications from Northeastern State University), Underwood decided to take a chance and audition for the fourth season of American Idol.
She auditioned in St. Louis in September 2004, at the age of 21. She sang a rendition of Bonnie Raitt’s “I Can’t Make You Love Me”.
Carrie Underwood’s American Idol audition starts with a home video of the future superstar feeding cattle (Credit: Fox)
Her down-to-earth attitude, paired with her big blonde hair, not to mention her fantastic voice, charmed judges Simon, Randy, and Paula, earning Underwood a spot in the competition.
You can watch her audition below to see the star in action. We forgot she told that story about getting a third nipple removed and clucked like her beloved farm chickens!
2005: Winning American Idol and Launching a Record-Breaking Music Career
During her time on the show, Carrie Underwood was a major fan favorite — even the grumpy Simon Cowell noted that she was a favorite to win the whole shebang.
According to producers, Underwood dominated when it came to votes from the public, garnering herself a loyal fan base that referred to themselves as “Carrie’s Care Bears” and dutifully voted for their favorite idol every week.
Carrie was 21 years old when she auditioned in St. Louis with “I Can’t Make You Love Me” by Bonnie Raitt (Credit: Fox)
After singing the country classic “Bless the Broken Road” by Rascal Flatts in the show’s finale, it was time to vote. In a monumental moment, Carrie Underwood was officially crowned the winner of the fourth season of American Idol, thanks to her widespread popularity among the public and the judges.
You can see her winning moment below — check out that deep-wave crimped hair, so 2005. Harold Elwin “Bo” Bice Jr. was the runner-up.
After her win, Underwood wasted no time and immediately began working on her career.
Her first single, “Inside Your Heaven,” was released later in June that year to massive success, debuting at number one on the Billboard Hot 100, breaking chart history as the first country singer to debut at the top of the chart.
In November 2005, Carrie Underwood released her debut album, Some Hearts, which is now regarded as a modern classic. It debuted at number one on the country charts and number two overall.
Singer Carrie Underwood poses with her awards in the press room at the 2006 Billboard Music Awards at the MGM Grand Garden Arena on December 4, 2006, in Las Vegas, Nevada (Credit: s_bukley / Shutterstock)
Some Hearts includes singles such as “Jesus, Take the Wheel”, “Don’t Forget to Remember Me”, and the iconic karaoke and girl’s night tune, “Before He Cheats” — it is no wonder that this album has become so iconic!
In December of 2005, Underwood was honored by her home state and was named the Oklahoman of the Year by Oklahoma Today.
Though this may not be as groundbreaking as some of her other achievements, it must have been nice to know that the people back home had her back.
2007: Grammy Wins and the Massive Success of Carnival Ride
Carrie Underwood was honored in 2007 by the Grammy Music Awards, earning her first nominations and awards for Best Female Country Vocal Performance for “Jesus, Take the Wheel” and the coveted Best New Artist award.
In October of that year, Underwood released her second album, Carnival Ride. This time around, Underwood was more involved in the songwriting and producing processes, which paid off.
The album debuted at number one on the Billboard charts and was certified double platinum in a mere two months — an impressive feat!
Singer Carrie Underwood arrives in a pink dress and peep-toe heels at the American Idol Season 8 Grand Finale held at Nokia Theatre L.A. Live on May 20, 2009, in Los Angeles, California (Credit: s_bukley / Shutterstock)
Even more, Victoria’s Secret named Carrie Underwood the Sexiest Female Musician in 2007, showing that people loved her looks just as much as her music.
Carrie Underwood Today: Family Life, Activism, and Record-Breaking Success
Since winning American Idol, Carrie Underwood has released a total of nine albums, which have earned the country music star seven Grammy Awards, 12 Billboard Music Awards, 17 American Music Awards, and 15 Academy of Country Music Awards.
Carrie Underwood wearing a bright red quilted jacket paired with a bold checkered blue scarf around her neck (Credit: Karl Piper / WENN)
Even though Underwood is busy with her music career, she has found time to carve out a fulfilling personal life. She married hockey player Mike Fisher in 2010, and the pair has two children together.
She is also an outspoken animal rights activist, using her large platform to urge politicians to do right by the animals she loves so much.
Carrie Underwood was supported by her husband, Mike Fisher, and their adorable 3-year-old son, Isaiah, while receiving a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on September 20, 2018, in Hollywood (Credit: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock)
Though many think Kelly Clarkson may be the richest previous American Idol winner, Carrie Underwood blows Clarkson’s $45 million net worth away, as her estimated worth is $140 million.
Underwood has sold more than 70 million records worldwide, making her one of the most successful female country artists and the most successful American Idol alum by far.
Carrie Underwood shows how to style a striking checkered blue scarf as she leaves the Radio 2 Studios in London on March 13, 2012 (Credit: Karl Piper / WENN)
Carrie’s style evolution has included everything from glamorous red carpet gowns to bold street-style statements — and in 2012, she gave fans a glittery footwear moment worth remembering.
Carrie Underwood Shines in Glittery Brian Atwood ‘Fruitera’ Booties at Rockefeller Plaza
In August 2012, we spotted Carrie Underwood in the ‘Fruitera’ booties from Brian Atwood during an appearance at Rockefeller Plaza.
Carrie Underwood’s glitter-infused ‘Fruitera’ booties by Brian Atwood add a bold, sparkling touch to her chic ensemble (Credit: Dan Jackman / WENN)
The Oklahoma-born country music singer, songwriter, and actress sported a bronzed glow, long curly locks, and a shimmery ensemble to match her glam booties.
Her shorts feature metallic brocade details, and the shimmer in her top complements them perfectly. While some may feel her look is a bit too much, we need to remember that she’s a glamorous pop-country singer. Therefore, she can’t go wrong with big hair, bold accessories, and sparkle.
Carrie Underwood performs live at Rockefeller Plaza as part of the Toyota Concert Series on August 15, 2012 (Credit: Dan Jackman / WENN)
Carrie’s look was glamorous, and the heels matched her outfit perfectly. She could have worn pumps or sandals, but I really like the shimmery booties for their unique feel.
An inside zip and glitter-infused fabric elevate an abbreviated bootie topped with a slim ankle strap
These booties feature covered heels and platforms with a zip-up design, along with an added ankle strap and buckle closure.
The darker suede trim complements the glittery upper. We love that these designer heels aren’t priced over $500, unlike many other styles we’ve seen. So, what do you think of Carrie Underwood’s shoe selection? Do you approve of the ‘Fruitera’ from Brian Atwood?
Carrie Underwood’s Iconic Shoe and Fashion Moments
From red carpet glamour to stage performances, Carrie Underwood consistently showcases her impeccable style. Here are some of her most memorable fashion and footwear highlights:
2019 CMA Awards: Nine Stunning Outfits
- Event: 53rd Annual Country Music Association Awards
- Outfits: Carrie dazzled in nine different ensembles, including a sheer gold Elie Madi gown paired with Jimmy Choo ‘Misty’ sandals and a green halter dress by The Blonds complemented by Giuseppe Zanotti ‘Harmony’ sandals.
- Footwear Highlights: Jimmy Choo ‘Lang’ sandals and Rene Caovilla ‘Stelina’ pumps added elegance to her looks.
- Read more: Carrie Underwood’s 2019 CMA Awards fashion highlights
2016 Grammy Awards: Elegant in Nicolas Jebran
- Event: 58th Annual Grammy Awards
- Outfit: A black strapless satin gown by Nicolas Jebran, featuring a thigh-high slit.
- Footwear: Black Giuseppe Zanotti slingback heels completed her sophisticated ensemble.
- Discover more: Carrie Underwood’s 2016 Grammy Awards look
Storyteller Tour: Black and Gold Glamour
- Event: “Storyteller Tour: Stories in the Round” concert in Las Vegas
- Outfit: A sheer black mini dress with a golden armor-inspired bodice and fringed skirt.
- Footwear: Knee-high lace-up boots with peep toes and stiletto heels added an edgy touch.
- See her look: Carrie Underwood’s bold stage outfit in Las Vegas
Promoting ‘Storyteller’ in London
- Event: Appearance on “Good Morning Britain”
- Outfit: A prim blue skirt suit paired with a pussy-bow blouse.
- Footwear: Matching blue Lori Silverman ankle boots, known for their Swarovski crystal embellishments.
- Explore her style: Carrie Underwood’s chic look in London
Academy of Country Music Awards: Sparkling in LaBourjoisie
- Event: 52nd Academy of Country Music Awards
- Outfit: A glittery, sheer gown by LaBourjoisie adorned with intricate silver beading.
- Accessories: Minimal yet impactful, including Harry Kotlar diamond earrings.
- Read more: Carrie Underwood’s sparkling ACM Awards appearance
These moments underscore Carrie Underwood’s status as a fashion icon, seamlessly blending elegance with bold footwear choices.
Discover More: American Idol’s Most Successful Stars
Carrie Underwood may be the richest American Idol winner, but she’s not the only one who found massive success after the show. From Kelly Clarkson to Jennifer Hudson, many contestants have built impressive careers and fortunes.
To see how Carrie stacks up against other Idol alumni, you must visit our in-depth feature on the richest American Idol contestants of all time.